12 Blogs 2: Christmas Movies of the SF Writers

Through hard work, and dark ale, and getting in touch with lots of old friends, and another of those odd, meaningful dreams I’ve been having lately, I managed to start feeling the faintest hint of Christmassy yesterday. So today I'm planning to decorate, then party in the evening.  (With, of course, hard work again in-between.) Today's blog is the first of (hopefully) three, rounding up the Christmas tastes of my fellow professionals.  (And there's an adventure for Scale Guy at the end.)  I asked my friends in the SF and Fantasy field what their favourite Christmas movie was.  And I got some entertaining answers...


'Trading Places, which while not about Christmas per se, takes place during the Christmas season and whose story, about the rich being humbled, the poor being elevated and good triumphing over greed, has a definite Dickens quality to it. Also: Jamie Lee Curtis at her height of hotness. Merry Christmas, indeed,' - John Scalzi (author, Old Man's WarThe Android's Dream, etc.)

 

Thanks, John.

 

‘My favourite Christmas movie vacillates wildly from year to year, but at the moment it's probably Rankin & Bass's stop-motion classic Santa Claus Is Comin' To Town, the "secret origin" of Santa Claus featuring the talents of Mickey Rooney and Fred Astaire. I grew up on the whole gamut of Rankin/Bass specials, and I have always been obsessed with the way that those little stop-motion figures seem to live in an alternate reality all their own, with different rules of physics and causality and such. (And while it isn't my "favourite" as such, the immortal Rudolph & Frosty's Christmas In July *absolutely* obsesses me at the moment in the way that it pulls together nearly all of the myriad Rankin/Bass Christmas specials into one unified continuity.)Chris Roberson (author, The Dragon’s Nine Sons, The Voyage of Night Shining White, etc.)

 

If I’d made up an archetypal Chris Roberson answer, it would have sounded just like that one.

 

‘Wow, even though I celebrate Christmas with the happy routines of family, friends, gift-giving, and celebration, I don't have a singular Christmas film that's "my film". I'd love to say The Nightmare Before Christmas, It's a Wonderful Life, A Christmas Story or even Elf, but none would be true, although all of these are good. When I think of a "favourite Xmas movie", I picture a favourite DVD that warmly slips into the player at this time of year to set the mood. Sadly, I don't have one. However - if the question were to include "favourite Christmas music”...’

 

Oh go on then, we’re due to be getting there in a couple of days anyway.

 

‘... then I'd have an answer locked and loaded. I'll share it anyway. James Brown’s Funky Christmas.

 

Really?

 

‘I can't remember a Christmas from the last 12 or 13 years that hasn't had this music in the background. If you can find this 17-track funkfest, snag it.  How can you miss with classics like this? "Go Power at Christmas Time", "Santa Claus Go Straight To The Ghetto", "Soulful Christmas", and "Tit for Tat (Ain't No Taking Back)".  I can honestly say that this is not only my favourite Christmas album of all-time, but it's so funny and funky, it still sounds great in mid-July, when it's 105 Fahrenheit outside.  I challenge anyone to listen to this and not be filled with holiday cheer and early 70's cheesy, funky joy.’

 

I’m sure some of our readers may take you up on that.

 

‘... RIP, James - you're still as good as it gets, and to all reading this, I dedicate track #5, "Let's Make Christmas Mean Something This Year." Happy Holidays, everyone, and best to you for the New Year,’ – John Picacio (artist, illustrator of renown.) 

http://www.amazon.com/James-Browns-Funky-Christmas-Brown/dp/B000001EFD

 

Thanks, John. 

 

Scrooged, starring Bill Murray. It's a fantastic updating of the Christmas Carol story, with hugely enjoyable cameos from more American character actors than you can shake a stick at. And it manages to be cynical and heart-warming at the same time, which is pretty Zen when you think about it,’ – Mike Carey (author, the Felix Castor series.)

 

Oh, that's a hard one. If I had to pick just one that I could watch over and over it would have to be Nightmare Before Christmas. It hits all the right notes for a holiday film - a love story, catchy music, presents and a happy ending. The fact that it is gorgeously art directed, dark and features a skeleton as the main character just add to the joy. I can't wait for a visit from Sandy Claws this year,’ – Mary Robinette Kowal (author, Evil Robot Monkey, Clockwork Chickadee, etc.)

 

Nobody’s going for the Muppets, are they? Oh, wait...

‘My favourite Xmas movie of all is the 1987 A Muppet Family Christmas, where Kermit and co. go to visit Fozzie's mother in her cabin, only to be snowed in with Doc and Sprocket from Fraggle Rock and an unexpected Sesame Street cast. It also has Fraggles living in tunnels below the house, and a dream sequence with Muppet Babies (the only Muppet show production to combine all the various shows).  There is a priceless moment where Janice (she of the Electric Mayhem) comes out asking "Does anybody want any Christmas cookies?" Prompting Cookie Monster to go berserk. Witnessing this, Animal says, "Dat my kind of fellow." What's not to love?’ – Lou Anders (publisher, Pyr Books.)

 

‘Lou's answer is the correct answer. Watch out for the icy patch!’ – Stephen Segal (editor, Weird Tales magazine.)

 

Well, we seem to be developing a consensus...

 

‘Aw, Lou got one of mine.  Choosing just one favourite is quite a challenge, but I think I'll have to go with the musical Scrooge with Albert Finney (who was young at the time but playing in old-age makeup that turned out to be eerily prescient). It's beautifully atmospheric, the fun scenes from Past and Present are wonderfully joyous, and it has one of the better Future sequences. Not only is there a truly scary trip to hell, but there's a catchy song-and-dance number that takes place during a funeral procession, with dancing on the coffin itself - and that's the song you'll be humming for hours. There's something rather twisted about that, but it works in context. It's the sort of sight that would make you change your life, if your death brought on a happy song-and-dance through the streets.  Though what my family always seems to end up watching at Christmas is an episode or two of Firefly,’ – Shanna Swendson (author, Damsel Under Stress, Don’t Hex with Texas, etc.)

 

A Muppet Christmas Carol, Scrooged (for the taxi scene with David Johansson), The Nightmare Before Christmas. But, top of the list, Takashi Minamoto's Until the Lights Come Back.  A satellite crashes into a Tokyo power station and the lights go out (it's Christmas Eve, obviously). Twelve people find their lives interconnecting and missing,’ – Jon Courtenay Grimwood (author, the Arabesk trilogy, End of the World Blues, etc.)

 

I’m sure many of you out there will be nodding along to that choice. 

 

A Christmas Story, a film set in the 1940s in which Our Hero, Ralphie, believes a Red Ryder BB Gun would be the ultimate Christmas gift, despite his mother, teachers, and Santa all telling him he'll shoot his eye out. It's charming and agonizing and wonderful and embarrassing. I love it,’ – C.E. Murphy (author, Urban Shaman, Hands of Flame, etc.)

 

It's a Wonderful Life is of course the best Christmas movie ever.  And so is the original Miracle On 34th Street.  And The Princess Bride which isn't a Christmas movie at all, but I love it so much I have to mention it once in every four emails,’ – Steven Moffat (new boss, Doctor Who.)

But there’s always one.  Or two...

 

‘I haven't seen any of the titles suggested so far. Christmas movies fill me with the same kind of atavistic horror that some people regard science fiction, but maybe that's because I'm watching the wrong ones. The titles that come to mind for me are Gremlins (that wonderful dead-Santa anecdote!), Die Hard and Batman Returns.  Happy solstice, everyone!Sean Williams (author, Saturn Returns, The Force Unleashed, etc.)

 

Batman Returns?! 

 

'That first episode of Tales From the Crypt (1972) where Joan Collins bludgeons her husband to death under the Christmas tree then has to barricade her suburban home against a slobbering homicidal maniac dressed as Santa Claus while she tries to get rid of the body - only for her sweet little daughter to let the killer in ... Ahhhh,' – Kim Newman (author, Anno Dracula, The Man from the Diogenes Club, etc.)

 

Yeah, thanks Kim... And a Merry Christmas to all of you at home!


The Adventures of the Amazing Scale Guy... Day One.

 

‘Scale Guy, Scale Guy, does whatever a Scale Guy does.  But he’s the best at what he does.  And what he does is demonstrate relative size.  Da de dah de dah...’

 

‘Mr. Pym, today you are that big.  And Mrs. Pym is that big.  Including the urn.  Ahem.’  

 

See you tomorrow!  Ho ho ho!  Cheerio!


20 Response to "12 Blogs 2: Christmas Movies of the SF Writers"

  • jmswallow Says:

    I'll echo Sean with my pick - Die Hard. "Now I have a machine gun. Ho Ho Ho." That says Christmas to me... (For other Xmas-related explosions and asskickery, The Long Kiss Goodnight is also a laff.


  • heatherfeather Says:

    I have two favorite Christmas movies-depending on my mood.

    When I'm feeling insulin shock from all of the holiday saccharine movies- "Bad Santa" starring Billy Bob Thorton. It never fails to elicite a laugh from me. But definitely not family-friendly!

    On a more traditional note: "The Bishop's Wife".
    Just a nice nostalgic movie which manages to incorporate the religious meaning of the holiday. I especially love David Nivan's ending "Empty Stocking" sermon which touches upon what the season should be about.

    Paul -Forgive me if you've addressed this, but did you write another "Who" Christmas story this year? I've enjoyed your last two very much.


  • Stephen Says:

    Hilarious stuff. I bet Scale Guy won't be invited to the funeral after that remark. I've no idea how they'll know how deep to dig the grave without him though . . .

    On a fanboyish note, there's no body. Urn or coffin? We'll have to wait and see.

    As for my favourite Christmas movie, sorry to be a killjoy but I don't really have one. It's more the kind of movies that are always shown around Christmas -- Gremlins is a good one, as is An American Tail -- that interest me.

    On a side note, has anybody ever noticed how many episodes of Ally McBeal were set at Christmas?


  • The Audio Time Team Says:

    My favorite Christmas movie is the 1966 Chuck Jones animated "How The Grinch Stole Christmas". It's a fairly accurate recreation of the original book and you can never go wrong with Boris Karloff singing. A truly wonderful reminder that Christmas is a lot more than popguns, roast beast, and ribbons.


  • Ash Says:

    I can't believe no-one mentioned National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation.

    It's a classic...!


  • Anonymous Says:

    I like the 1951 Alister Simm version of Scrooge.

    I also like Frank Capras It's A Wonderful Life. Love the way that the film takes you on a journey to despair and back again in the space of two hours. I don't think they've managed to top it since.

    More modern movies with Christmas theme I enjoy would be Scrooged and Trading Places. But the two mentioned above are my all time favs.


  • govikes Says:

    Agreed. The Alastair Sim version of Scrooge and the 1985 George C. Scott version a close second.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8gOU8XJc7Y


  • Anonymous Says:

    If I’d made up an archetypal Chris Roberson answer, it would have sounded just like that one.

    Ha ha ha ha. Yes.

    But Catie Murphy gave the correct answer: A Christmas Story. I would also add Muppets Christmas Carol, Love, Actually and the Holiday Special of The Office (UK), which I watch every year as I wrap presents, usually fast forwarding through the most excruciating David Brent public appearances segments.

    --Jen Heddle


  • Rani Says:

    Well, no one seemed to mention "Close Encounters of the Third Kind", that for me, does have a holiday feeling. Any holiday. But if we go to the more traditional movies, I guess "It's a Wondeful Life" would be it. I just love Frank Capra's movies.

    Also, what Sean said: "Gremlins".


  • RAB Says:

    Stephen: Scale Guy was not happy about having to attend Bill Foster's burial just so everyone could see Foster was still giant-sized. He also blames himself for Jan, as he believes what happened to her was actually a foreshortening error that could have been avoided had he been standing next to her. Everyone just thought she was big because he wasn't there to prove otherwise. But tragically, the Silent Easter project took up all his time.

    Only one vote for A Christmas Story? For shame! Kudos to C.E. for showing impeccable taste, though.


  • The Sword Is Drawn Says:

    I'd have to side with Mr Carey, on the subject of Christmas movies. Scrooge, for me (A child born at the tail end of the 70s, but very much raised in the 80s), is very much my Christmas movie. Sure, Muppet's Christmas Carol has a very special place in the hearts of my girlfriend and I, but for me Scrooged is my marker for a Christmas movie. So brilliantly 80s, for one reason. It's a rarity these days that we get a movie which can both be so terribly cynical and feel-good in equal doses, but Scrooged strikes a balance. It's dark, it's funny, and damn it if I can't find it on this year in the Radio Times I'm off to find it on DVD.;D

    Bill Murray at the height of his comedy game. Pure class.


  • Tim Says:

    Planes Trains & Automobiles, which actually takes place before Thanksgiving is an old time fave...
    Christmas Carol...The George C Scott version (with a guest appearance by Turlough).
    Nightmare before Christmas
    Christmas Story


  • Russell Finn Says:

    Audio Time Team: That's not Boris Karloff doing the singing; that's the late Thurl Ravenscroft (better known to many as the voice of Tony the Tiger).

    I agree with everything else you said, though. Chuck Jones is one of the greatest filmmakers of the 20th century.


  • pbristow Says:

    "Batman Returns?! "

    I agree entirely, Paul. Surely that one's for *Easter*?

    (G,D&RVVF)


  • Paul Cornell Says:

    Thanks, all. This is proving quite popular, must do it again next year. Heather: thank you for non action movie choices, and no, none of the broadsheets have the budget for fiction this year, it seems. We did try, and will try again next year. And love the David Niven speech. I must find this Muppet movie everyone's talking about, Jen. Rab and Stephen: you guys should really be writing Scale Guy, not me.


  • Bat Masterson Says:

    The. Thin. Man.

    It's not Christmas without Nick and Nora!


  • Paul Cornell Says:

    Actually, I so agree. That's one of my favourite movies.


  • Rich Johnston Says:

    No sci-fi writer mentions BRAZIL? For shame...


  • Karen Funk Blocher Says:

    Your distinguished panel hit all of my faves except two: Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol (not sure that really counts as a film) and You've Got Mail, in which an independent bookstore owner in NYC is driven out of business between Halloween and Christmas. I'm very fond of A Christmas Story and Miracle on 34th St (the original, mind you). Last night, as it happens, I watched one of my favorite scenes from The Princess Bride before switching over to some genuine Christmas selection that was entirely forgettable.


  • Owl Says:

    Oh yes, I forgot that Batman Returns was set at Christmas but all wonderfully Tim Burtonised. It's high time I upgraded to a DVD version.